Mdubz
When making these we were a little concerned about the icing consistency but they turned out surprisingly good. 🙂
Reply
I just popped over from Stumble Upon. 🙂 LOOOOVE it! 😉
Mdubz
When making these we were a little concerned about the icing consistency but they turned out surprisingly good. 🙂
Just made these. Only yielded 12 for me… I think I made them a little big… Still delectable though. Oh… and now they’re gone. Awesome!
My daughter loves oreos, this would be the best cookies to make for her. I love your blog, I will stay to follow.
Pingback: AiB: Homemade Oreos : Perlkönig
Pingback: It’s Monday! :: Meal Planning « Precious Little Poppets
I just need to find unsalted butter and shortening and then I’m all set. I’m currently living in Brazil, where I’m having a hard time finding either.
sydney!
hahaha your sense of humor is awesome. just sayin’
Holli Mayer
You’re hilarious, and I can’t wait to make these. I was salivating over them at SK, and now it’s nice to see another angle on how to conquer this deliciousness. Cheers!
Joanne
Wow – they look delicious. Bet they are much better than the real thing!
Allison
just made these! YUM!
Amanda
So I just made these and YUM!!! I made a double batch, half made with the regular filling and half with crushed peppermint in the filling. Awesome recipe (found on Pinterest) thanks ;o)
Teddy
Just made these (again) not half an hour ago. Sooo good! I crushed up some peppermint candy canes and added them to the filling for an extra christmas-y effect. Thanks!
Mark C
As concerning substituting. You can easily substitute regular cocoa for dutch process with out much difference bu cannot do dutch for regular……
Pingback: Homemade Oreos « If Found Please Read
I just made these with my kids…they were absolutely delicious! Thanks for sharing…
I’m making these tonight. If my spawn stop playing video games/ texting/ whatever the one does in the bathroom for 3 hours, long enough to eat these, I will be mighty impressed. I know they look awfully good to me and anything compared to an “Oreo on crack” sounds fantastic.
YES!!!!!! These are too good! My spawn LOVED them, and for a moment, I wasn’t lame to them anymore!!! My husband actually left his chair to get another! I think these cookies are magic! Awesome recipe!!!
Marieke
Thank you so much for this recipe! They turned out a little bit too big, but they taste awesome. Geez, i’m gonna make so many new friends tomorrow ! 😉
Jen
These Oreos are fantastic!! I just made a double batch of them and they are delicious. The only thing I did differently was that I cooled the cookies in the fridge right after they came out of the oven (before I assembled them). They still turned out great. My whole dorm expresses eternal gratitude 🙂
thebrewingbaker
yum! I made these – so great. and I love your blog title:)
Pingback: Baking Sweets | Pearltrees
I am making Flour Bakery’s homemade oreos now, which is pretty similar but has even more chocolate. I can’t wait! Yours look gorgeous.
Loretta
Oh boy. I just made these and they are truly amazing! Mine had a little more ‘chew’ than a regular Oreo, and I used all butter instead of shortening. I ate a few and froze the rest. I’m going to make cookies and cream ice cream…Next time I’ll try a mint variation!
Samantha
These sound great! I really like double stuffed oreos so i was wondering if there was filling left over or would it be best to double the filling recipe?
Madison
I have these in the oven and I keep stealing little pieces of the dough! Also, I don’t have a food processor or a fancy mixer- I did it with my hand mixer and though I was skeptical at first and I got fine powder all over the place, I was relieved to see it work! I eventually had to stop mixing and squish all the dough together myself, but still…it worked! Now onto the cream filling 🙂
Jordana!!!!! I’m literally in awe. I had to let you know that I follow your every foodie move in the blogosphere because I have a new infatuation with cooking/baking and you’re obv the master. Keep posting gurl, my roommates and I are forever grateful for these recipes!
Pingback: Friday Mash Up: 5 Delicious Baking Ideas | Kitchen Idiots
kitchenidiots
I know this is a pretty old post but I just stumbled upon it. Sister, I love your work!
http://www.howmanycaloriesinabanana.net/2013/01/calories-in-banana.html
Pingback: Homemade Oreos And Milk
chelsey
Fact #1: This was a really funny recipe article. It made me laugh, therefor I automatically assume you are more awesome than you claim these cookies are.
Fact #2: I am in need of increasing the population of friends, so I will attempt these cookies this weekend to reel some new ones in. 😛
Fact #3: Fact 2 was just a joke.
Fact#4: Fact 3 was a lie.
Thank you 🙂
Pingback: Homemade Oreos | The Stiles Family
Oreos on crack?! SIGN ME UP! Juuuust kidding. But those oreos DO looks absolutely delicious =)
These look delicious, not sure if we can get Oreo’s here in the UK and have never tried them so look forward to giving your recipe a try! Have pinned too 🙂
Pingback: Homemade Oreos | the nonpareil baker
I “stumbled” here and I am making these now . .yummy! Thanks for sharing this recipe. I have a feeling I am going to love these!
Why, yes, I will bookmark this recipe and make them pronto. Thanks for sharing! These look amazing!
Kim
About how many do you get out this recipe.
Pingback: Homemade Oreos – Recetas Recordantes
